Production decisions
The same reference at both ends
When the manufacturer and the recipient check against different criteria, every batch becomes an argument. An identical inspection fixture at both ends turns that argument into a comparison.
There is a kind of quality problem that lies not in the part, but between two companies.
The supplier says what they send is good. The customer says what they receive is bad. Both have checked. Both are right according to their own criteria. And that is exactly the problem: they do not share the same criteria.
The case
A fixture for checking continuous web: the stripe and hologram applied to tickets on a reel. The web passes through the fixture, and a template lets the operator compare the position and angle of the stripe and hologram against their permitted limits.
It was made for the machines that apply the stripe and hologram, and for the cutters too. Every machine has its own: after a certain number of metres, the operator passes a section of the reel through the fixture. If the stripe and hologram are within the limits, the machine continues. If not, it needs readjusting. An arrow on the fixture itself shows the hologram's direction of travel, so there is no doubt about how to position the web.
What happened next
Later, there was an issue with the material.
And a new need appeared, not from our customer but from our customer's customer: they wanted to check for themselves that the stripe they received was correct.
The answer was simple: manufacture additional units of the fixture and send them over.
From then on, the inspection reference was present not just where the material was made, but also where it was received. Both ends could check the web against the same criteria.
Years later, another batch of fixtures was ordered.
Why it works
When supplier and customer check differently, each has their own truth. One measures with a caliper, the other by eye with a ruler. One looks at the centre, the other at the edge. One applies the drawing tolerance, the other the tolerance they remember.
With a shared reference, the conversation changes:
- The criteria are no longer disputed, because they are the same.
- The result is discussed, and it can be seen and repeated at both ends.
- Issues are detected earlier. The customer can inspect on receipt rather than discovering them on the line.
- The supplier can check exactly the same thing the customer will check, before shipping.
And that has an effect that is not measured but is felt: trust. When both sides see the same thing, nobody needs convincing.
What it takes to make it work
Sharing a fixture is about more than making two alike.
They must really be identical. The same geometry, the same template, the same references. If one is manufactured differently, you have created two criteria with the same name.
They must be easy to use without training. The recipient does not know your process. If the fixture needs explanation, it will be used incorrectly at the other end. That is why details such as the direction-of-travel arrow matter.
They must be replaceable. If the fixture breaks or gets lost at its destination, another identical one must be manufacturable without relying on someone remembering what it was like.
And they should be verifiable. A master part or a known reference lets both sides check that the fixture is still saying the same thing.
Beyond the fixture
The idea applies even without a physical fixture.
If you have a recurring disagreement with a supplier or a customer, before arguing about the batch, ask yourself:
- Are we checking the same thing? The same characteristic, in the same place, with the same tolerance.
- With the same means? A caliper and an eye do not give the same result.
- Can we share the reference? A fixture, a master part, a template, a limit sample signed off by both sides.
Often, the quality problem between two companies is solved as soon as both look through the same opening.
At 7Axis Industrial, we design inspection fixtures that can be reproduced and distributed: across workstations, across plants or between supplier and customer. The same criteria everywhere.
View the complete project → Quality, inspection and poka-yoke →