Workshop practice
An expensive fixture is shared. An inexpensive one is multiplied.
The first inspection fixture worked so well that the sections fought over it. The solution was not to make it better, but to make it inexpensive enough for every workstation to have its own. Unit cost is a design decision too.
There was only one fixture at the start of the family. A box with three interchangeable templates for checking chip position in cards.
It was intended for one particular section. But it began to be used for everything: checking cards, setting up machines, approving the first part, carrying out random checks. Operators used it, and so did quality staff.
And because there was only one, it circulated. It went from one workstation to another, from one section to another. And what always happens with a good tool when there is only one happened: the sections fought over it.
What happens with a shared fixture
A shared tool seems efficient: you buy it once and everyone uses it. In practice, it has problems that never appear in a quotation.
- It is never where it is needed. When an operator needs it, another section has it.
- If it is not there, the check gets skipped, or people return to the old method. In this case, the transparent sheet aligned by hand.
- It wears out faster, gets knocked more and is lost more often, because it travels.
- And nobody feels responsible for it, because it belongs to nobody.
A quality check that depends on the tool being available is not a check. It is a good intention.
The way forward: one for every workstation
The solution was not to make a better fixture. It was to make more fixtures.
And that was only possible because each unit cost little. The body was engineering-grade ABS and the template polycarbonate: readily available materials that can be manufactured quickly and need no manual adjustment unit by unit.
From there, the family grew in a way that would not have been possible with an expensive fixture:
- The individual fixture came directly from that dispute. One fixture per reference, with a fixed template, kept at the workstation without depending on anyone else.
- The customer decided to implement the system across almost all their production equipment, so every operator had a quick check within reach.
- For reel work, every machine has its own. One at each stripe and hologram application station, and at the cutters.
- When an issue arose with the material, extra units were made for our customer's customer so they could check what they received. Without a second thought.
- And years later, another batch was ordered.
None of that would have happened if each fixture had cost ten times as much. One would have been bought and shared, and the good idea would have stayed at a single workstation.
Designing for multiple units
When a fixture is intended for many workstations, unit cost stops being a detail in the quotation. It is a design requirement, just like accuracy or strength.
And designing for multiple units has its own rules:
- Materials you can find. If one unit needs a special material with a lead time of weeks, so does the tenth.
- Manufacturing without individual adjustment. If every unit needs hand adjustment, each comes out slightly different. And if the units are not identical, every workstation ends up checking against different criteria.
- Parts that can be replaced separately. If a template gets scratched, replace the template, not the fixture.
- Replacement should not be a drama. A fixture that breaks or gets lost must be easy to manufacture again, identical to the first.
- It should not need its designer. Not to use it, understand it or order another.
The question that changed everything: what for?
There is a detail in this story that explains why the fixture could be inexpensive.
The first ones were made in engineering-grade ABS, as a step before making them in aluminium. It was the usual path: test in plastic and, once it works, make it "properly" in metal.
But they went to work, were used every day, opened and closed hundreds of times, and held up. So the question changed. It was no longer "when do we switch to aluminium?", but "what for?"
And there was no answer. The fixture does not bear loads or heavy impacts, its accuracy comes from its geometry rather than its material, and aluminium would only have added cost. That cost, multiplied across every workstation, would have been precisely what stopped the family growing.
Before moving a prototype to a "final" material, it is worth asking that same question:
- Has anything failed in actual use?
- What does the new material offer that the part actually needs?
- How many units will there be? A one-off part is not the same as a family distributed throughout a factory.
If the answers do not justify the change, the prototype is not a draft. It is the solution. And sometimes it is also what lets that solution reach everywhere.
At 7Axis Industrial, we design fixtures with the number needed in mind too: so they can be manufactured, distributed and replaced without the good idea staying at just one workstation.