Production decisions
Check what does the checking too
An inspection fixture is a reference. If that reference moves, wears out or gets confused with another, everything checked against it becomes questionable. Three design decisions to keep the fixture telling the truth.
Quality control measures the part. But there is a question asked far less often: who checks the fixture?
A gauge, a template or an inspection fixture is the measuring stick. If that stick has shifted, every part checked against it is judged incorrectly. Worst of all, nobody notices, because the fixture still "works": parts fit, are compared and are approved.
In a family of card and ticket inspection fixtures, three design decisions answered that question.
1. The master parts travel with the fixture
The multiple fixture compares the milling of the chip recess against a transparent template. It has three interchangeable templates, one for each card reference.
Any template can lose alignment: a knock, an assembly that has not seated properly, a screw that loosens. If that happens, the fixture starts approving offset cards or rejecting good ones.
The solution is simple: the base of the fixture stores three master cards, one per template. These are known good cards, with the milling in the correct position.
Before continuing work, the operator inserts the master card and checks that the template still matches it. If it does, the fixture is right. If it does not, the problem is known before judging a single production part.
What matters is where the masters are: inside the fixture. A master that has to be fetched from somewhere else is a master that stops being used. One kept in the base itself gets used.
2. Every template has its place
Templates not currently in use are a risk too. Stored loose, they get scratched, bent, lost or mixed up.
That is why the multiple fixture stores its three filters within the assembly itself, stacked in modules.
And the inspection set came about precisely because of this problem. As the system spread through the factory, every section wanted its own templates, and filters were passed from one workstation to another. The set brings together almost all the references at the inspection station, each with its own template, and has a recess for storing all the ones that are not fitted. The template on top is changed to suit the order, and work continues.
This is poka-yoke applied to storage: if every template has one place and one place only, it is hard to pick the wrong one or find it damaged.
3. Every fixture has an identity
The third decision goes one step further.
Some fixtures in the family have an NFC tag in the base. Bringing a phone close opens the record for that particular fixture in a management platform, where photographs, results and observations from each check can be recorded.
The chosen tag is not a simple label: it is a chip with cryptography that can generate authentication messages verifiable by a server. Configured this way, it makes it possible to know that the reading comes from that particular fixture rather than a copy.
This changes what using a fixture means. It is no longer just "I checked this card", but "I checked it with this fixture, on this date, with this result, and here is the photo". The check stops staying in the operator's head and becomes evidence.
And if a fixture is later found to have been out of alignment, it is possible to know what was checked with it and since when.
What they have in common
All three decisions follow the same idea: an inspection fixture also needs to be checked.
- The masters check that the reference is still correct.
- The storage recesses prevent the reference from being damaged or mixed up.
- The identity records which reference was used for each check.
None of the three is expensive or complicated. What matters is that they are considered from the outset, as part of the fixture, rather than added afterwards.
If you have inspection fixtures in your plant
A few quick questions:
- How do you know your fixture is still right today? If the answer is "because it has not caused any problems", you do not know.
- Do you have a master part? And is it close to the fixture or in a drawer in another section?
- Where are templates or accessories stored when they are not being used?
- Could you find out which parts were checked with a particular fixture if tomorrow you discovered it was out of alignment?
If any answer makes you uncomfortable, that is where the improvement lies.
At 7Axis Industrial, we design inspection fixtures with their verification, storage and traceability in mind too. A check is only as good as its reference.
View the complete project → Quality, inspection and poka-yoke →