Workshop practice
Draw the tolerance, not the nominal dimension
A checking template that marks where something should be forces the operator to decide how much error is too much. One that marks the permitted limits leaves just one question: inside or outside? What I learned from making dozens of card templates.
For years, in many card factories, chip position was checked with a transparent sheet. The operator placed it on the card, slid it with their fingers until the edges lined up and then looked to see whether the chip was where it should be.
That sheet had two problems. The first was obvious: it had to be aligned by hand every time, which took time and depended on each person's steady hands.
The second was less obvious, and is what this article is about: the sheet marked where the chip should be. It did not mark the limits of where it could be.
The problem with drawing the nominal dimension
A template that marks the nominal position — the ideal location, the dimension on the drawing — seems the most logical. After all, that is what the drawing says.
But in practice, no part lands exactly on the nominal dimension. Every part deviates a little, some more than others. The operator then faces a mark and a chip that do not quite match and has to decide:
Is this a little or a lot?
And they have no reference for that question. Only their judgement, experience, eyesight and time pressure. What one person calls "a tiny bit off, good enough", the next calls "this is not going out". And the same operator may decide differently at seven in the morning and seven in the evening.
A template that draws the nominal dimension does not remove the operator's judgement. It leaves them without a measuring stick.
Drawing the limits
The polycarbonate templates I made for the inspection fixture family do something else: they mark the maximum permitted tolerance. Not where the chip should be, but the boundary of the area where it is accepted.
That changes the operator's question completely. It is no longer "how far has it shifted?", but:
Is it inside or outside?
That question can be answered at a glance. It does not require experience, does not depend on the shift, and two different people give the same answer. The decision is still the operator's, but now it is based on something written down rather than something they have to imagine.
It is the same principle as a go/no-go gauge in a machine shop: nobody measures the hole; they check whether the plug fits. The template is a visual go/no-go gauge.
What needs to be resolved for it to work
Drawing the limits sounds as easy as drawing two lines instead of one. It is not quite that simple. Three things determine whether the template tells the truth.
1. The reference must always be in the same place
Perfectly drawn limits are useless if the template is positioned slightly off. A misplaced template turns good parts into bad ones, and vice versa.
That is why the templates in these fixtures are not aligned by hand: they sit in a hinged lid with stops and pins that fit into the nest. The card fits snugly in its recess, the lid comes down, the stops position it, and the reference always stays in the same position relative to the card.
Without this, drawing the tolerance makes no sense. The template tolerance can never be finer than the repeatability of its positioning.
2. The line has thickness
Any screen-printed or printed line has a width. And if the limit lies on a line a few tenths of a millimetre wide, a very practical question arises: is the limit the inside edge of the line, the outside edge or the centre?
If that is not decided, every operator interprets it differently and the original problem returns. It must be decided when designing the template, drawn accordingly and known by everyone using it. And the line should be as fine as the marking process allows while remaining clearly visible.
3. The template must rest on the part
If the template is separated from the card by even a couple of millimetres, parallax appears: the line seems to fall in a different place depending on where you look from. Two people of different heights can see different things.
In these fixtures, the lid does not remain at a distance: it lowers until the template rests on the card and holds everything in place. With the reference touching the part, the viewing angle no longer matters.
Beyond cards
This applies to any visual check using a template, mask or transparency: positions of printing, labels, holes, inserts or components.
If you have checking templates in your plant, it is worth reviewing them with these questions:
- Do they mark the ideal position or the permitted limits? If they mark the ideal position, every operator is applying their own tolerance.
- Are they always positioned the same way? If they are aligned by hand, the tolerance you draw makes no difference.
- Is it clear which part of the line is the limit?
- Do they rest on the part, or are they viewed from a distance?
- Do you have a master part to check that the template is still correctly positioned?
A well-made template does not replace the operator. It gives them a measuring stick that is the same for everyone, on every shift.
At 7Axis Industrial, we design and manufacture custom inspection fixtures and checking templates, with guided positioning and references that mark what is acceptable and what is not.
View the complete project → Quality, inspection and poka-yoke →